ALGEBRAIC FORMS
627
we may write in general
Ds c = ΣD(p1p2p3…) 𝑓,
the summation being for every partition (p1p2p3…) of s, and D(p1p2p3…) 𝑓 being = Σ(Dp1 𝑓1 )(Dp2 𝑓2 )(D p3 𝑓3 ) 𝑓4…𝑓m.
Ex. gr. To operate with D2 upon (213)(214)(15), we have
D(2) 𝑓 = (13)(214)(15) + (213)(14)(15),
D(12) 𝑓 = (122)(213)(15) + (213)(213)(14) + (212)(214)(14),
and hence
D(2) 𝑓 = (214)(15)(13) + (213)(15)(14) + (213)(212)(15) + (213)2(14) + (214)(212)(14).
Application to Symmetric Function Multiplication.—An example will explain this. Suppose we wish to find the coefficient of (52413) in the product (213214)(15).
Write
(213)(214)(15) = … + A(524)(13) + …;
then
D5D4
2D3
1(213)(214)(15) = A;
every other term disappearing by the fundamental property of Ds. Since
D5(213)(214)(15) = (13)(14)(14),
we have:—
D4
2D3
1(14)(14)(13) = A
D3
2D3
1{(13)(13)(13) + 2(14)(13)(12)} = A
D2
2D3
1{5(13)(12)(13) + 2(14)(12)(1) + 2(13)(13)(1)} = A
D2D3
1{12(12)(12)(1) + 7(13)(1)(1) + 2(14)(1) + 6(13)(12)} =A
D3
112(1)3 = A,
where ultimately disappearing terms have been struck out. Finally A = 6 · 12 = 72.
The operator d1 = a0∂a1 + a1∂a2 + a2∂a3 + … which is satisfied by every symmetric fraction whose partition contains no unit (called by Cayley non-unitary symmetric functions), is of particular importance in algebraic theories. This arises from the circumstance that the general operator
λ0a0∂a1 + λ1a1∂a2 + λ2a2∂a3 + …
is transformed into the operator d1 by the substitution
(a0, a1, a2, … as, … ) = (a0, λ0a1, λ0λ1a2, … , λ0λ1 … λs−1as, … ),
so that the theory of the general operator is coincident with that of the particular operator d1. For example, the theory of invariants may be regarded as depending upon the consideration of the symmetric functions of the differences of the roots of the equation
a0xn − (n
1) a1xn − 1 + (n
2) a2xn − 2 − … = 0;
and such functions satisfy the differential equation
a0∂a1 + 2a1∂a2 + 3a2∂a3 + … + nan−1∂an = 0.
For such functions remain unaltered when each root receives the same infinitesimal increment h; but writing x − h for x causes a0, a1, a2 a3, … to become respectively a0, a1 + ha0, a2 + 2ha1, a3 + 3ha2, … and 𝑓 (a0, a1, a2 a3, …) becomes
𝑓 + h(a0∂a1 + 2a1∂a2 + 3a2∂a3 + …) 𝑓,
and hence the functions satisfy the differential equation. The important result is that the theory of invariants is from a certain point of view coincident with the theory of non-unitary symmetric functions. On the one hand we may state that non-unitary symmetric functions of the roots of a0xn − a1xn − 1 + a2xn − 2 − … = 0, are symmetric functions of differences of the roots of
a0xn − 1!(n
1) a1xn−1 + 2!(n
2) a2xn−2 − … = 0;
and on the other hand that symmetric functions of the differences of the roots of
a0xn − (n
1) a1xn−1 + (n
2) a−
2xn−2 − … = 0;
are non-unitary symmetric functions of the roots of
a0xn − a11!xn−1 + a22!xn−2 − … = 0.
An important notion in the theory of linear operators in general is that of MacMahon's multilinear operator ("Theory of a Multilinear partial Differential Operator with Applications to the Theories of Invariants and Reciprocants," Proc. Lond. Math. Soc. t. xviii. (1886), pp. 61–88). It is definied as having four elements, and is written
(μ, ν; m, n)
=1m [ μam0
0∂αn + (μ + ν)m!(m − 1)! 1!am−1
0a1∂αn+1
+ (μ + 2ν) { m!(m − 1)! 1!am−1
0a2 + m!(m − 2)! 2!am−2
0a2
1 } ∂αn+2
+ (μ + 3ν) { m!(m − 1)! 1!am−1
0a3 + m!(m − 2)! 1! 1!am−2
0a1a2
+ m!(m − 3)! 3!am−3
0a3
0 } ∂αn+3
+ … ] ,
the coefficient of ak0
0ak1
1ak2
2 … being m!k0!k1!k2!…. The operators a0∂α1 + a1∂α2 + …, a0∂α1 + 2a1∂α2 + … are seen to be (1, 0; 1, 1) and (1, 1; 1, 1) respectively. Also the operator of the Theory of Pure Reciprocants (see Sylvester Lectures on the New Theory of Reciprocants, Oxford, 1888) is
(4, 1 ; 2, 1) = 12{ 42
0∂α1 + 10a0a1∂α2 +6(2a1a2 + a2
1)∂α2 + … } .
It will be noticed that
(μ, ν; m, n) = μ(1, 0; m, n) + ν(0, 1; m, n).
The importance of the operator consists in the fact that taking any two operators of the system
(μ, ν; m, n) ; (μ1, ν1; m1, n1)
the operator equivalent to
(μ, ν; m, n)(μ1, ν1; m1, n1) − (μ1, ν1; m1, n1)(μ, ν; m, n),
known as the "alternant" of the two operators, is also an operator of the same system. We have the theorem
(μ, ν; m, n)(μ1, ν1; m1, n1) − (μ1, ν1; m1, n1)(μ, ν; m, n) = (μ1, ν1; m1, n1);
where
μ1 = (m1 + m − 1) { μ1m1(μ + n1ν) − μm(μ1 + nν1) } ,
ν1 = (n1 − n)ν1ν + m − 1m1μ1ν − m1 − 1mμν1.
m1 = m1 + m − 1,
n1 = n1 + n,
and we conclude that quâ "alternation" the operators of the system form a "group." It is thus possible to study simultaneously all the theories which depend upon operations of the group.
Symbolic Representation of Symmetric Functions.—Denote the elementary symmetric function as by αs
1s!, αs
2s!, αs
3s!, … at pleasure; then, taking n equal to ∞, we may write
1 + a1x + a1x2 + … = (1 + ρ1x) (1 + ρ2x) … = eα1x = eα2x = eα3x = …
where
as = Σρ1ρ2…ρs = αs
1s! = αs
2s! = αs
3s! = … .
Further, let
1 + b1x + b2x2 + … + bmxm = (1 + σ1x)(1 + σ2x)…(1 + σmx);
so that
1 + a1σ1 + a2σ2
1 + … = (1 + ρ1σ1)(1 + ρ2σ1)… = eσ1α1,
1 + a1σ2 + a2σ2
2 + … = (1 + ρ1σ2)(1 + ρ2σ2)… = eσ2α2,
⋅⋅⋅⋅⋅
1 + a1σm + a2σ2
m + … = (1 + ρ1σm)(1 + ρ2σm)… = eσmαm;
and, by multiplication,
(1 + a1σ + a2σ2 + … ) = (1 + b1ρ + b2ρ2 + … + bmρm),
= eσ1α1 + σ2α2 + … + σmαm.
Denote by brackets () and [ ] symmetric functions of the quantities ρ and σ respectively. Then
1 + a1[1] + a2
1[12] + a2[2] + a3
1[13] + a1a2[21] + a3 + …
+ ap1ap2ap3…apm[p1p2p3…pm] + …
= 1 + b1(1) + b2
1(12) + b2(2) + b3
1(13) + b1b2(21) + b3(3) + …
+ bq1
1bq2
2bq3
3…bqm
m(mqmm−−1qm−1…2q21q1) + …
= eσ1α1 + σ2α2 + … + σmαm.
Expanding the right-hand side by the exponential theorem, and then expressing the symmetric functions of σ1, σ2, …σm, which arise, in terms of b1, b2, … bm, we obtain by comparison with the middle series the symbolical representation of all symmetric functions in brackets () appertaining to the quantities ρ1, ρ2, ρ3, … To obtain particular theorems the quantities σ1, σ2, σ3, … σm are auxiliaries which are at our entire disposal. Thus to obtain Stroh's theory of seminvariants put
b1 = σ1 + σ2 + … + σm = [1] = 0;
we then obtain the expression of non-unitary symmetric functions of the quantities ρ as functions of differences of the symbols α1, α2, α3, …
Ex. gr. b2
2(22) with m = 2 must be a term in
eσ1α1 + σ2α2 = eσ1(α1−α2) = … + 14!σ4
1(α1 − α2)4 + …,
and since b2
2 = σ4
1 we must have
(22) = 124(α1 − α2)4 = 124(α4
1 + α4
2) − 16(α3
1α2 + α1α3
2) + 14α2
1α2
2
= 2a4 − 2a1a3 + a2
3
as is well known.
Again, if σ1, σ2, σ3…σm be the m, mth roots of − 1, b1 = b2 = … = bm−1 = 0 and bm = 1, leading to
1 + (m) + (m2) + (m3) + … = eσ1α1 + σ2α2 + … + σmαm
and
∴ (ms) = 1ms!(σ1α1 + σ2α2 + … + σmαm)sm,